How are Mortgages Approved?


Automated Approval Engines


What Are Automated Approval Engines? Automated approval engines are sophisticated technology platforms that utilize algorithms, artificial intelligence (AI), and machine learning (ML) to assess mortgage applications. These engines expedite the underwriting process by quickly analyzing borrower data, evaluating risk, and providing loan decisions with minimal human intervention.

Key Features:

  • Speed and Efficiency: Automated approval engines can process applications in minutes, significantly reducing the time it takes to approve a loan.
  • Accuracy: By minimizing human error, these engines ensure more accurate evaluations.
  • Consistency: Provides uniformity in decision-making, ensuring that all applications are assessed using the same criteria.

Popular Automated Approval Engines:

  1. Desktop Underwriter (DU) by Fannie Mae:
    • Overview: One of the most widely used automated underwriting systems in the mortgage industry.
    • Functionality: DU evaluates the credit risk of the borrower by analyzing credit scores, employment status, income, assets, and other relevant factors.
    • Benefits: Provides lenders with a comprehensive risk assessment, helping them make informed lending decisions quickly.
  2. Loan Prospector (LP) by Freddie Mac:
    • Overview: Another leading automated underwriting system, used by many lenders for conventional loans.
    • Functionality: LP assesses the borrower's creditworthiness by examining credit reports, income, assets, and other pertinent data.
    • Benefits: Offers a streamlined process for lenders, with quick turnaround times for loan approvals.
  3. TOTAL Scorecard by FHA:
    • Overview: The Technology Open To Approved Lenders (TOTAL) Scorecard is an automated underwriting system used for FHA loans.
    • Functionality: TOTAL Scorecard evaluates the borrower's credit risk by considering their credit history, debt-to-income ratio, and other factors.
    • Benefits: Helps lenders determine eligibility for FHA-insured loans, ensuring compliance with FHA guidelines.
  4. GUS (Guaranteed Underwriting System) by USDA:
    • Overview: An automated underwriting system used for USDA Rural Development loans.
    • Functionality: GUS assesses the borrower's eligibility for USDA loans by analyzing credit, income, and property information.
    • Benefits: Facilitates the approval process for USDA loans, making it easier for borrowers to obtain financing for rural properties.
  5. DU Refi Plus and LP Relief Refinance:
    • Overview: Automated systems designed for refinancing loans under specific programs.
    • Functionality: These systems streamline the refinancing process by evaluating the borrower's current loan status, credit history, and property value.
    • Benefits: Provide faster approvals for refinancing, helping borrowers take advantage of lower interest rates or better loan terms.

Technologies Behind Automated Approval Engines:

  • Artificial Intelligence (AI) and Machine Learning (ML):
    • Role: AI and ML algorithms analyze vast amounts of data to identify patterns and predict borrower behavior.
    • Benefits: Enhance the accuracy and efficiency of the underwriting process, reducing the risk of default.
  • Robotic Process Automation (RPA):
    • Role: RPA automates repetitive tasks such as data entry and document verification.
    • Benefits: Frees up underwriters to focus on more complex aspects of the loan approval process, improving overall productivity.
  • Credit Scoring Models:
    • Role: Automated approval engines use advanced credit scoring models to assess the creditworthiness of borrowers.
    • Benefits: Provide a more comprehensive evaluation of a borrower's financial health, leading to better lending decisions.

Importance of Automated Approval Engines:

  1. Improved Turnaround Time:
    • Automated approval engines can process loan applications in minutes, significantly reducing the time it takes for borrowers to receive a decision.
  2. Cost Savings:
    • By automating the underwriting process, lenders can reduce labor costs and improve operational efficiency.
  3. Enhanced Customer Experience:
    • Faster approvals and fewer errors lead to a smoother, more satisfying experience for borrowers.
  4. Regulatory Compliance:
    • Automated systems ensure that all loan applications are evaluated according to the same criteria, helping lenders maintain compliance with regulatory requirements.
  5. Competitive Advantage:
    • Lenders using automated approval engines can offer quicker, more efficient service, giving them an edge in a competitive market.

Even with automated approvals, borrowers are still required to submit a variety of documents to support their mortgage application. Here’s a detailed rundown of the typical documents needed:

1. Mortgage Application Information

  • Loan Application Form (1003): This is the standard mortgage application form used by lenders to record important information about the potential borrower.

2. Income Verification

  • Pay Stubs: Typically, pay stubs from the last 30 days are required to verify current income.
  • W-2 Forms: W-2 forms from the past two years help verify employment and income history.
  • Tax Returns: Two years of federal tax returns may be required, especially for self-employed individuals, freelancers, or those with variable income.
  • Profit and Loss Statements: For self-employed borrowers, year-to-date profit and loss statements may be necessary.
  • Social Security, Disability, or Pension Income: Documentation of any additional income sources, such as award letters or 1099 forms.

3. Assets and Debts

  • Bank Statements: Recent statements (typically the last two months) for all checking, savings, and investment accounts to verify assets.
  • Retirement Account Statements: Statements from retirement accounts like 401(k)s or IRAs.
  • Gift Letters: If part of the down payment is a gift, a letter from the donor stating that the funds are a gift and not a loan.
  • Liabilities: Documentation of any outstanding debts, such as credit card statements, car loans, student loans, and other personal loans.

4. Credit Verification

  • Credit Report: The lender will pull a credit report to assess the borrower’s credit history and score.
  • Explanations for Credit Issues: If there are any negative marks on the credit report, the borrower may need to provide written explanations.

5. Other Documentation

  • Identification: A government-issued ID, such as a driver’s license or passport.
  • Proof of Homeowner’s Insurance: Evidence of homeowner’s insurance for the property being purchased.
  • Purchase Agreement: A signed purchase agreement between the buyer and seller.
  • Appraisal Report: A report from a licensed appraiser assessing the value of the property.
  • Rental History: For borrowers without substantial credit history, a rental history report or verification of rent payments.

How Automation Helps

While the list of required documents might seem extensive, mortgage automation software streamlines the process in several ways:

  • Document Collection: Automated systems can guide borrowers through the document collection process, providing checklists and reminders.
  • Verification: Automation tools can quickly verify the authenticity of documents, reducing the time and effort required for manual checks.
  • Storage and Organization: All documents are stored electronically, making it easier to manage and access them throughout the underwriting process.
  • Error Reduction: By automating calculations and checks, the risk of human error is minimized.



Manual Approvals

When a borrower does not qualify for an automated approval, the application may be referred to a manual underwrite. Here's a detailed explanation of what happens in such cases:

When Automated Approval Fails

Reasons for Rejection: Automated approval engines are designed to quickly assess the risk of lending to an applicant based on standardized criteria. However, not all borrowers fit neatly into these criteria. Common reasons for automated rejection include:

  • Low Credit Score: Borrowers with lower-than-required credit scores.
  • High Debt-to-Income (DTI) Ratio: Borrowers whose debt obligations are too high relative to their income.
  • Limited Credit History: Borrowers with insufficient credit history to make a reliable assessment.
  • Unusual Income Sources: Self-employed individuals, freelancers, or those with seasonal income may not have the consistent income patterns that algorithms prefer.
  • Recent Financial Issues: Borrowers with recent bankruptcies, foreclosures, or other negative marks on their credit report.

What is Manual Underwriting?

Definition: Manual underwriting is the process in which a human underwriter reviews the mortgage application in detail to determine the borrower's creditworthiness. Unlike automated systems, manual underwriting allows for a more nuanced evaluation of a borrower's financial situation.

Process:

  1. Detailed Document Review:
    • The underwriter examines all the financial documents submitted by the borrower, including income statements, tax returns, bank statements, and credit reports.
  2. Debt-to-Income Ratio (DTI):
    • The underwriter calculates the borrower's DTI ratio to ensure it falls within acceptable limits. Manual underwriting often adheres to stricter DTI guidelines, typically around 31/43, though exceptions can be made for strong files with compensating factors.
  3. Verification of Income and Employment:
    • The underwriter verifies the borrower's employment status and income sources, which may involve contacting employers or requesting additional documentation.
  4. Credit History Analysis:
    • The underwriter looks beyond the credit score to understand the context of any negative marks. They may consider explanations for late payments, medical bills, or other unique circumstances.
  5. Asset and Liability Assessment:
    • The underwriter evaluates the borrower's assets and liabilities to determine their overall financial health.
  6. Property Appraisal:
    • An appraisal of the property to be purchased is reviewed to ensure it meets the lender's criteria and is valued appropriately.
  7. Rental History Verification:
    • For borrowers without a substantial credit history, verifying consistent rental payments can be crucial.
  8. Compensating Factors:
    • The underwriter may consider compensating factors such as a large down payment, significant savings, or a strong employment history that can offset other areas of concern.

Benefits of Manual Underwriting:

  • Flexibility: Allows for a more individualized assessment, which can be beneficial for borrowers with unique financial situations.
  • Consideration of Context: Takes into account the context behind financial issues, allowing for a more comprehensive evaluation.
  • Opportunity for Approval: Provides a pathway for borrowers who may not meet the standard criteria but are still creditworthy.

Challenges:

  • Time-Consuming: Manual underwriting takes longer than automated processes, often requiring several days to weeks for a decision.
  • More Documentation: Borrowers may need to provide additional documentation and respond to more inquiries from the lender.
  • Stricter Criteria: Manual underwrites often adhere to stricter guidelines, particularly concerning DTI ratios and credit history.

Conclusion

Manual underwriting serves as a crucial alternative for borrowers who do not qualify for automated approval. By allowing a human underwriter to assess the application in detail, it provides a more flexible and nuanced evaluation process. While it can be more time-consuming and require additional documentation, manual underwriting offers a valuable opportunity for borrowers with unique financial situations to secure mortgage approval.


Learn more